Standards Comparison

    CMMI

    Voluntary
    2023

    Process maturity framework for organizational performance improvement

    VS

    APRA CPS 234

    Mandatory
    2019

    Australian prudential standard for information security resilience

    Quick Verdict

    CMMI drives voluntary process maturity globally via appraisals for predictable delivery; APRA CPS 234 mandates information security capability for Australian financial entities with strict testing and notifications. Organizations adopt CMMI for benchmarking, CPS 234 for regulatory compliance.

    Process Maturity

    CMMI

    Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI)

    Cost
    €€€€
    Complexity
    High
    Implementation Time
    12-18 months

    Key Features

    • Defines 6 maturity levels from incomplete to optimizing
    • Organizes 25 practice areas into 4 category areas
    • Offers staged and continuous representation options
    • Uses SCAMPI A/B/C appraisals for benchmarking
    • Enforces generic practices for institutionalization
    Information Security

    APRA CPS 234

    APRA Prudential Standard CPS 234 Information Security

    Cost
    €€€€
    Complexity
    High
    Implementation Time
    12-18 months

    Key Features

    • Board ultimate responsibility for information security
    • 72-hour APRA notification for material incidents
    • Systematic risk-based testing of controls
    • Third-party capability and control assessments
    • Asset classification by criticality and sensitivity

    Detailed Analysis

    A comprehensive look at the specific requirements, scope, and impact of each standard.

    CMMI Details

    What It Is

    Capability Maturity Model Integration (CMMI) is a performance improvement framework for process institutionalization. Primarily for software, services, and acquisition, it uses maturity and capability levels to enhance predictability and quality through structured practices.

    Key Components

    • 4 category areas (Doing, Managing, Enabling, Improving) with 12 capability areas and 25 practice areas in v2.0.
    • Maturity levels 0-5; capability levels 0-3 per area.
    • Generic goals/practices for institutionalization; specific practices per area.
    • SCAMPI appraisals for certification.

    Why Organizations Use It

    • Improves delivery predictability, reduces rework, boosts ROI.
    • Meets contractual requirements in defense, regulated sectors.
    • Manages risks via measurement, governance.
    • Builds competitive edge, stakeholder trust via benchmarks.

    Implementation Overview

    • Phased: assessment, piloting, rollout, appraisal, sustainment.
    • Tailors to Agile/DevOps; pilots high-impact areas like requirements, configuration.
    • Applies to mid-large orgs in IT, software, services globally.
    • Requires authorized SCAMPI A for official ratings.

    APRA CPS 234 Details

    What It Is

    APRA Prudential Standard CPS 234 (Information Security) is a binding regulation issued by the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority for regulated financial entities. Effective from 1 July 2019, it mandates maintaining information security capabilities commensurate with threats to ensure resilience against incidents impacting confidentiality, integrity, or availability of information assets, including those managed by third parties. It adopts a risk-based, assurance-driven approach focused on governance and outcomes.

    Key Components

    • **Governance and accountabilityBoard ultimate responsibility, defined roles.
    • **Risk managementAsset classification by criticality/sensitivity, commensurate controls.
    • **Third-party oversightCapability assessments, control evaluations.
    • **Incident responseDetection mechanisms, annual testing of plans.
    • **AssuranceSystematic testing, internal audit reviews. No fixed control count; 36 paragraphs outline requirements with APRA notifications (72 hours for incidents, 10 days for weaknesses).

    Why Organizations Use It

    Mandatory for APRA-regulated entities (banks, insurers, super funds) to avoid penalties, heightened supervision. Enhances cyber resilience, stakeholder trust, operational continuity; integrates with CPS 220/230 for holistic risk management.

    Implementation Overview

    Phased: gap analysis, policy framework, asset inventory, controls, testing program. Applies to all sizes proportionally; requires evidence-based audits, no formal certification but APRA scrutiny. (178 words)

    Key Differences

    Scope

    CMMI
    Process improvement across development, services, acquisition
    APRA CPS 234
    Information security governance and cyber resilience

    Industry

    CMMI
    Cross-industry, global (software, IT, defense)
    APRA CPS 234
    Australian financial services (banks, insurers, super)

    Nature

    CMMI
    Voluntary performance framework with appraisals
    APRA CPS 234
    Mandatory prudential regulation with enforcement

    Testing

    CMMI
    SCAMPI appraisals (A/B/C) by certified appraisers
    APRA CPS 234
    Systematic independent control testing annually

    Penalties

    CMMI
    Loss of certification, no legal penalties
    APRA CPS 234
    Regulatory sanctions, fines, supervisory actions

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Common questions about CMMI and APRA CPS 234

    CMMI FAQ

    APRA CPS 234 FAQ

    You Might also be Interested in These Articles...

    Run Maturity Assessments with GRADUM

    Transform your compliance journey with our AI-powered assessment platform

    Assess your organization's maturity across multiple standards and regulations including ISO 27001, DORA, NIS2, NIST, GDPR, and hundreds more. Get actionable insights and track your progress with collaborative, AI-powered evaluations.

    100+ Standards & Regulations
    AI-Powered Insights
    Collaborative Assessments
    Actionable Recommendations

    Check out these other Gradum.io Standards Comparison Pages